How to Find and Hire Top Senior Finance Executives in 2025

The Growing Challenge of Hiring Senior Finance Executives

As companies navigate an increasingly complex financial landscape, the demand for skilled finance executives has never been higher. According to a 2024 Deloitte report, 78% of CFOs and finance leaders say they face difficulty finding qualified talent for senior roles. The combination of talent shortages, rising compensation expectations, and a competitive hiring market means businesses must be strategic in their finance recruiting efforts.

This post explores the challenges in hiring senior finance executives, the best places to source top candidates, and how partnering with an executive search firm like Wenlock Talent can help companies secure the right leadership for their finance teams.

The Challenges of Hiring Senior Finance Executives

1. Identifying Leadership and Strategic Thinking

Senior finance executives do more than crunch numbers—they drive business growth, risk management, and long-term financial planning. However, finding candidates with a blend of technical expertise and leadership ability can be difficult.

Key qualities to look for in finance leaders include:

• Strategic decision-making and problem-solving skills

• Strong business acumen and industry knowledge

• Experience in financial forecasting and risk assessment

• The ability to communicate complex financial data to stakeholders

Since these traits aren't always evident on a resume, structured executive assessments and thorough interview processes are essential.

2. Navigating a Competitive Talent Market

With demand for CFOs and senior finance professionals increasing, companies must differentiate themselves to attract top talent.

Key challenges in the finance recruitment landscape include:

• A shrinking pool of experienced finance leaders

• Compensation expectations that outpace company budgets

• Increased competition from private equity-backed firms and startups

Employers should focus on employer branding and strong candidate engagement strategies to stand out in the hiring market.

3. Compensation and Retention Strategies

The best finance executives expect competitive compensation packages that go beyond salary. According to a 2024 Payscale report, CFOs in the U.S. earn a median base salary of $395,000, with bonuses and stock options often increasing total compensation.

To attract and retain top finance talent, companies should consider offering:

• Equity and performance-based bonuses

• Flexible work arrangements and executive perks

• Professional development opportunities

Retention strategies are just as important as recruitment—without a clear growth path, even the best hires may leave for better opportunities.

Where to Find Top Finance Talent

1. Leveraging Professional Networks and Industry Associations

Traditional job boards may not be the best way to find high-level finance executives. Instead, businesses should tap into finance-specific networks and industry groups, such as:

• Financial Executives International (FEI)

• CFA Institute

• Association for Financial Professionals (AFP)

Attending finance conferences, executive summits, and leadership forums can also be valuable in identifying and building relationships with potential candidates.

2. Utilizing an Executive Search Firm for Finance Recruiting

For many businesses, working with an executive search firm is the most effective way to secure top-tier finance talent. Specialized finance recruitment firms like Wenlock Talent offer:

• Access to a curated network of high-level finance professionals

• Targeted outreach and discreet executive search processes

• Expertise in negotiating competitive compensation packages

Unlike standard recruiting firms, executive search firms focus on long-term placement and leadership alignment, ensuring a perfect cultural and strategic fit.  

Best Recruitment Strategies for Finance Professionals

1. Crafting a Clear and Attractive Job Description

A well-written job description should outline:

• Key responsibilities and expectations

• Required qualifications and industry experience

• Opportunities for growth within the company

To appeal to top finance executives, highlight the company’s vision, leadership culture, and long-term strategy.

2. Conducting Thorough Executive Assessments

Beyond standard interviews, companies should use:

• Behavioral and situational assessments

• Finance-specific case studies and real-world problem-solving exercises

• 360-degree reference checks from past colleagues and industry peers

Using data-driven hiring techniques can help ensure candidates have both the technical skills and leadership capabilities required.

3. Ensuring a Strong Cultural Fit

A successful finance executive isn't just skilled—they align with the company's values and leadership style.

• Encourage in-depth conversations with leadership teams during the hiring process.

• Consider trial consulting periods before a full-time hire to assess fit.

• Provide structured onboarding and mentorship programs for new executives.

How Wenlock Talent Helps Companies Find Senior Finance Professionals

1. Our Expertise in Finance Executive Search

At Wenlock Talent, we specialize in executive search for finance professionals, helping companies identify and secure high-impact finance leaders. Our process includes:

• In-depth market analysis to find the best candidates

• A tailored executive search strategy based on company needs

• Comprehensive candidate assessments to ensure the right fit

2. The Wenlock Talent Advantage

Partnering with Wenlock Talent provides businesses with:

• Exclusive access to pre-vetted finance talent

• A seamless and confidential hiring process

• Expert guidance on market trends and compensation

Our proven track record in finance recruiting ensures companies hire with confidence and build a finance team that drives long-term success.

Secure Top Finance Talent with Wenlock Talent

The challenges of hiring senior finance executives require a strategic and proactive approach. By leveraging industry networks, refining hiring strategies, and working with an experienced executive search firm, companies can find and retain top finance leaders who drive business growth.

If your company is looking for a trusted partner in finance executive search, Wenlock Talent is here to help. Our team specializes in connecting businesses with top-tier finance professionals for long-term success. Contact us today to discuss your finance recruitment needs and find your next great leader.  

‍