Struggling to Hire a Finance Manager? Here’s How to Fix It

The role of a finance manager is crucial to any organization’s success. These professionals ensure financial health, shape strategy, and drive growth. However, hiring finance managers comes with its own set of challenges. With the demand for finance leaders projected to grow by 17% through 2030 (according to BLS), businesses must overcome hurdles like identifying leadership skills, retaining top talent, and addressing skills gaps.

In this blog, we’ll explore these challenges in depth and offer actionable solutions to ensure you attract and retain the best finance talent for your organization.

Understanding the Key Challenges in Hiring Finance Managers

Identifying Leadership Skills

Leadership is a non-negotiable quality for finance managers, yet assessing this during the hiring process is often tricky. Many companies overemphasize technical expertise, overlooking whether candidates can lead teams and strategize effectively.

Actionable Tip: Behavioral interviews are a great way to gauge leadership skills. Ask candidates how they’ve led through challenges, managed team conflicts, or influenced major decisions.

Retaining Top Finance Talent

Retaining high-performing finance professionals can be just as challenging as finding them. With competitive offers from other organizations, burnout risks, and limited growth opportunities, it’s easy for companies to lose their best talent.

Did You Know? According to Gallup, employees who feel engaged and valued are 59% less likely to look for a job elsewhere.

Actionable Tip: Foster a culture of recognition and growth. Offer mentorship opportunities, performance-based bonuses, and flexible work arrangements.

Discover Wenlock Talent’s employee retention strategies.

Navigating the Skills Gap

Finance management is no longer just about crunching numbers. Modern finance managers must understand automation, data analytics, and strategic forecasting. Unfortunately, the talent pool often lags behind these evolving needs.

Actionable Tip: Partner with specialized training programs or offer internal upskilling initiatives. This ensures candidates or current employees stay competitive in today’s tech-driven finance landscape.

Solutions to Overcome Challenges in Hiring Finance Managers

Refine Your Job Description

An effective job description attracts top-tier talent while weeding out unqualified candidates. Focus on balancing leadership and technical skills in your posting.

Pro Tip: Use clear, inclusive language that appeals to a diverse pool of candidates. For example, instead of “must be an expert,” try “seeking experience in…”

Assess Leadership Potential Effectively

Leadership simulations and situational questions are excellent tools for identifying candidates with strategic vision and people management skills. Psychometric assessments can also help ensure you’re evaluating potential rather than just past performance.

Offer Competitive Benefits and Growth Opportunities

Today’s finance professionals value growth as much as compensation. Provide professional development budgets, flexible work options, and clear career paths to retain top talent.

Partner with a Specialized Recruiting Agency

Recruitment agencies like Wenlock Talent specialize in connecting companies with pre-vetted finance professionals. We focus on finance recruitment strategies that prioritize leadership and cultural fit, saving you time and resources.

For tips on improving hiring practices, check out this SHRM guide.

How Wenlock Talent Can Help You Find and Retain Finance Managers

At Wenlock Talent, we specialize in sourcing top-tier accounting and finance talent. Our human-centered approach ensures that both businesses and candidates benefit from a smooth, tailored recruitment process.

Whether it’s crafting a compelling job description, identifying leadership potential, or creating retention strategies, we’re here to make the hiring process a little easier and a lot more human.

Contact us today to learn how we can help your business succeed.

Hiring a finance manager might seem daunting, but with the right strategies in place, you can overcome these challenges and secure the talent your business needs to thrive.

Ready to transform your hiring process? Wenlock Talent is here to help. Let us connect you with finance leaders who will drive your business forward.

‍